what it basiclly boils down to is your pissed that your precious Phoenix/goddess is gone so to cope you beat up on Rachel by saying she's a lame copy and a rip off you just need to get over it. She's gone and she's not coming back until Marvel is darn good and ready to bring her back. BTW Somone could just as easily say that "The Ultimate" and "The End" Jean are just cheap rip off's since they aren't the original 616 Jean.
I'am fire made flesh power incarnate I'am DARK PHOENIX!