Actually I was argeeing with you. I was answering to Borednow.

There is no doubt that their going with Jean being crazy and needing to gain control of her larger than life powers. Than the evil Jean who tries to kill everyone and dies.....again! That barely even worked in the comics mainly b/c at her Phoenix is Jean and Jean is not evil. She loses herself and then comes back. Plus Jean paying for crimes she committed while not completely sane is criminal. We hav institutes for people like that not prison or death. Plus she does pay in comic by having "rd." them all at the point of death.

There's only 6 billion people on the planet so it would be funny for them to try kill 5 billion to make Jean evil.

:darkphoenix: Swallows most of Earth's population.
:cyclops: Oh god Jean, how could you?
:emma: Thanks darling there goes all of my favourite resort areas.
:jean: I would have eaten an other planet but....burp...so far nothing else is inhabited.
:shadowcat: You couldn't have swallowed Emma too!
Fire Made Flesh